Comparison of BLE and GPS IoT Technologies

The Internet of Things (IoT) landscape has numerous technologies that serve different purposes, and Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) and Global Positioning System (GPS) IoT are two key players. While both are used for location-based services and device communication, their working principles, applications, and benefits vary significantly.

 

Related Pages:

  • BLE Gateways
  • BLE Beacons
  • BLE Cloud, Server, PC & Mobile
  • BLE Accessories
  • GPS IoT Devices
  • GPS IoT Cloud, Server, PC & Mobile
  • GPS IoT Accessories
  • GPS IoT Resources

 

Working Principles

Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE):

Also known as Bluetooth Smart, operates on the 2.4 GHz ISM (industrial, scientific, and medical) band, utilizing frequency hopping spread spectrum (FHSS) and Gaussian Frequency Shift Keying (GFSK) modulation. BLE is a low-power wireless communication protocol optimized for short-range data exchange between devices. Its communication protocol allows it to be used in applications that require intermittent, low-bandwidth data transmission, making it highly energy-efficient. BLE employs the Generic Access Profile (GAP) and Generic Attribute Profile (GATT) for defining device roles and enabling device communication.

 

GPS IoT:

Also known as Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS), functions by triangulating signals from multiple satellites orbiting the Earth. It uses the L1, L2, and L5 frequency bands, with modulation techniques like Binary Phase Shift Keying (BPSK) for signal encoding. GPS operates as a one-way communication system, where the GPS receiver captures signals from satellites to calculate the device’s precise location in real-time. Unlike BLE, GPS is best suited for tracking objects over large distances and relies heavily on direct line-of-sight communication with satellites.

 

Work Conditions and Environments

BLE:

Is ideal for environments where short-range communication is required. It is frequently deployed indoors, such as in hospitals, offices, retail stores, and smart homes. For example, BLE is used in healthcare to track medical equipment and patient movements in hospitals. Another use case is in retail environments, where BLE beacons can help deliver personalized content to customers based on their location within a store. However, BLE’s effectiveness diminishes over long distances or when there are significant obstructions, like thick walls or multiple floors in a building.

 

GPS IoT:

Excels in outdoor applications where long-range, precise location tracking is needed. GPS is widely used in vehicle navigation systems, fleet management, and asset tracking across global supply chains. For instance, GPS is vital for tracking cargo as it moves between different locations, ensuring real-time updates on shipment status. GPS may not perform well in densely populated urban areas with tall buildings, as signal obstructions can hinder accurate location determination.

In some cases, using BLE and GPS together enhances operational efficiency. For instance, BLE can be used to locate assets within a warehouse, while GPS can track these assets in transit once they leave the warehouse. This hybrid approach provides seamless indoor and outdoor tracking.

 

Benefits and Strengths

BLE:

Offers several advantages, primarily related to its low power consumption, which allows devices to run on small batteries for extended periods. This makes BLE an excellent choice for wearable devices, smart sensors, and IoT applications where energy efficiency is paramount. BLE devices also have a relatively low cost, making them suitable for mass deployment in industries like healthcare and retail. For example, BLE beacons can operate for months or even years on a single battery, significantly reducing maintenance costs.

 

GPS IoT:

On the other hand, provides unparalleled accuracy in global location tracking. Its ability to track objects or individuals across vast distances, such as from one country to another, makes it indispensable for applications like global logistics, transportation, and agriculture. GPS also works in a wide variety of weather conditions and does not rely on terrestrial infrastructure, making it suitable for remote or rugged environments.

 

Combining BLE and GPS:

Offers the best of both worlds, especially in asset tracking and fleet management. For instance, BLE can monitor assets within confined spaces like warehouses, while GPS provides continuous tracking of these assets during transit, offering end-to-end visibility.

 

Technology Standards

BLE:

Must comply with several international technology standards, including IEEE 802.15.1, which outlines specifications for short-range wireless communication in personal area networks (PAN). BLE devices also adhere to Bluetooth Special Interest Group (SIG) specifications, which ensure interoperability across devices from different manufacturers.

 

GPS:

Follows standards such as the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) standards for satellite communication. Additionally, the United States Department of Defense (DoD) sets specific regulations for GPS use, given its military origins.

 

International Government Standards

Internationally, both BLE and GPS are governed by multiple standards and regulations:

  • BLE:

Is governed by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) and International Organization for Standardization (ISO) standards, ensuring compliance across various industries.

  • GPS:

Compliance is enforced by bodies like the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) and the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) for civil aviation applications.

 

U.S. Government Standards

In the United States, BLE must comply with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Part 15 regulations, which govern unlicensed radio frequency devices. BLE systems used in healthcare are also subject to Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulations.

For GPS IoT, devices need to comply with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) regulations. GPS receivers must also align with Department of Defense (DoD) standards, especially for military or government-related applications.

 

Canadian Government Standards

In Canada, BLE is regulated by Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED), which ensures that BLE devices meet specific emission standards for wireless communication. Additionally, devices used in healthcare must comply with Health Canada’s regulations for medical devices.

GPS IoT systems in Canada are also governed by ISED, which regulates the usage of satellite communications. GPS applications in transportation must comply with Transport Canada’s standards for vehicle and fleet tracking systems.

 

Case Studies

  • New York, USA – A major retail chain integrated BLE beacons across several stores to track customer foot traffic and deliver targeted promotions. This led to increased engagement and personalized shopping experiences.
  • Houston, USA – A logistics company combined GPS and BLE to track the movement of containers both within its warehouse and during cross-country transit. This dual-system approach improved inventory visibility and reduced loss.
  • Chicago, USA – A healthcare facility deployed BLE-based patient tracking systems, streamlining internal processes and enhancing patient care through real-time location services.
  • Toronto, Canada – A municipal transportation agency used GPS to track buses across the city and BLE for in-terminal tracking, improving efficiency and providing real-time updates to passengers.

 

Our products are in stock and can be shipped overnight to Continental U.S. and Canada from one of our local warehouses. If you have any questions, our technical experts can help you. Please fill out this form or email us.