Wi-Fi HaLow vs. GPS IoT: A Comprehensive Comparison

Wi-Fi HaLow and GPS IoT are both transformative technologies in the Internet of Things (IoT) landscape, each designed for specific use cases. While Wi-Fi HaLow specializes in low-power, long-range communication, GPS IoT focuses on global positioning and navigation, offering distinct strengths when applied independently or in combination.

 

Related Products: 

  • GPS IoT Trackers/Devices
  • GPS IoT Tracking Accessories
  • GPS IoT Tracking Resources
  • GPS IoT – Cloud, server, PC & mobile Systems
  • Wi-Fi HaLow Gateways/Routers 
  • Wi-Fi HaLow End Devices 
  • Wi-Fi Halow – Cloud, Server, PC & Mobile Systems 
  • Wi-Fi HaLow Accessories 
  • Wi-Fi HaLow Resources

 

Working Principles: Frequencies, Modulation Techniques, and Communication Protocols

Wi-Fi HaLow:

Operates in the sub-1 GHz band, typically around 900 MHz, and uses Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) as its modulation technique. It’s an extension of the IEEE 802.11ah standard, optimized for long-range communication with lower power consumption, making it ideal for IoT applications in rural and remote areas. The low-frequency band allows Wi-Fi HaLow signals to travel farther and penetrate obstacles more effectively than traditional Wi-Fi.

 

GPS IoT:

On the other hand, functions using satellites that transmit signals at specific frequencies, such as L1 (1575.42 MHz) and L2 (1227.60 MHz). GPS relies on Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) for signal transmission. The technology is central to navigation systems, tracking, and positioning applications that require precise location data. GPS IoT devices receive signals from multiple satellites to triangulate an exact position on Earth, with an accuracy that can be down to centimeters.

Commonality:

Both Wi-Fi HaLow and GPS IoT enable wireless communication, but Wi-Fi HaLow focuses on data transfer over a local network, while GPS IoT emphasizes global positioning.

 

Work Conditions and Best-Suited Environments 

Wi-Fi HaLow:

Thrives in environments where long-range, low-power communication is essential, especially in industrial and agricultural applications. For instance, a farming operation can deploy Wi-Fi HaLow to monitor soil conditions, moisture levels, and weather data from sensors spread across acres of land. In smart cities, Wi-Fi HaLow enables seamless connectivity for traffic lights, parking systems, and utility meters.

 

GPS IoT:

Excels in applications requiring real-time tracking and location-based services. It is widely used in transportation, logistics, and fleet management to track vehicle locations, improve route efficiency, and provide real-time updates on shipments. For example, a trucking company can use GPS IoT to track the precise location of its trucks and manage delivery schedules effectively.

 

Combined Use:

Integrating Wi-Fi HaLow with GPS IoT can enhance applications like asset tracking. GPS IoT provides the location data, while Wi-Fi HaLow ensures long-range communication to transmit that data back to a central system, even in remote or rural areas.

 

Benefits and Strengths

Wi-Fi HaLow:

Has the advantage of operating at lower frequencies, which means it can cover larger areas with fewer access points and penetrate obstacles like walls or foliage. This makes it highly energy-efficient, with longer battery life for IoT devices. It also supports hundreds of devices per access point, perfect for large-scale deployments.

 

GPS IoT:

Offers unmatched accuracy for location-based applications. Its global coverage makes it invaluable for tracking assets across international borders, managing fleets, or even aiding in search and rescue operations. The strength of GPS IoT lies in its reliability and ability to function in various conditions, from urban environments to open seas.

 

Combined Benefits:

When used together, Wi-Fi HaLow and GPS IoT can create a comprehensive system where long-range communication and precise positioning converge. For instance, an emergency response team could benefit from GPS tracking to locate individuals and Wi-Fi HaLow to communicate vital information across large, challenging terrains.

 

Technology Standards

Wi-Fi HaLow:

Follows the IEEE 802.11ah standard, an extension of the traditional Wi-Fi protocols optimized for IoT. It complies with established Wi-Fi standards for device interoperability, ensuring it can integrate with existing Wi-Fi networks and devices.

 

GPS IoT:

Adheres to the standards set by the U.S. government’s Global Positioning System (GPS), which is managed by the Department of Defense (DoD). GPS devices must meet stringent accuracy and reliability standards, especially in sectors like aviation, maritime, and public safety.

 

International Government Standards and Regulations

Wi-Fi HaLow:

Must comply with international regulations governing wireless communications. This includes frequency allocation rules set by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), which ensures that Wi-Fi HaLow devices don’t interfere with other wireless communications. In Europe, devices must meet CE certification standards, while in Asia, local regulations may apply to ensure signal integrity and safety.

 

GPS IoT:

Is regulated by multiple international standards bodies. The International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) oversees the use of GPS in aviation, while the International Maritime Organization (IMO) ensures GPS standards are upheld in shipping and maritime applications. These organizations set performance, accuracy, and reliability standards for GPS devices.

 

U.S. Government Standards and Regulations

Wi-Fi HaLow:

Must comply with Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations, particularly around spectrum use. The FCC defines which frequency bands can be used for Wi-Fi HaLow and sets power output limits to prevent interference with other communications systems.

 

GPS IoT:

Falls under the oversight of the U.S. Department of Transportation (DoT) and the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA). These bodies set performance standards for GPS devices used in critical sectors such as transportation, emergency response, and national security.

 

Canadian Government Standards and Regulations

In Canada, Wi-Fi HaLow must adhere to the rules set by Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED), which regulates the use of radio frequency spectrum. Devices must be certified by ISED to ensure they meet Canadian standards for safety and performance.

GPS IoT in Canada is also regulated by ISED, particularly in sectors like transportation and public safety. Canadian GPS devices must comply with performance standards similar to those set by the U.S., ensuring accuracy and reliability for navigation and tracking.

 

GAO Case Studies

  • Los Angeles, California – A smart city initiative used Wi-Fi HaLow for connecting traffic lights and parking sensors over large areas, while GPS IoT tracked the city’s public transportation fleet. The combination improved traffic flow and reduced emissions.
  • Chicago, Illinois – An agricultural project leveraged Wi-Fi HaLow for monitoring crop health over thousands of acres, and GPS IoT for tracking equipment across the farm’s vast fields.
  • Houston, Texas – A logistics company used GPS IoT to monitor its vehicle fleet across multiple states, with Wi-Fi HaLow providing the necessary long-range communication between regional hubs.
  • New York City, New York – A construction company utilized GPS IoT to track equipment in real-time on large, complex building sites, while Wi-Fi HaLow connected security and monitoring systems.
  • Denver, Colorado – A smart utility network deployed Wi-Fi HaLow to monitor water and gas meters, while GPS IoT ensured accurate geolocation of meters for efficient service and repairs.
  • Toronto, Ontario – A transportation company used GPS IoT for tracking delivery vehicles across Ontario, while Wi-Fi HaLow enabled long-range communication at remote depots for logistical coordination.

 

Our products are in stock and can be shipped overnight to Continental U.S. and Canada from one of our local warehouses. If you have any questions, our technical experts can help you. Please fill out this form or email us.